Suing for Anxiety and Emotional Distress After a Car Accident

All Practice Areas

Emotional trauma following a car accident can be life-altering. While most people associate personal injury claims with broken bones or physical damage, a growing area of law acknowledges the real and lasting psychological injuries people suffer after collisions — even without visible wounds.

If you’re struggling with anxiety, PTSD, or emotional instability after a crash, you may be eligible for compensation. This guide covers everything you need to know about how to sue for emotional distress after a car accident — including what qualifies as emotional distress, how to prove your case, and how much compensation you could receive.

 

What Is Emotional Distress in a Car Accident Case?

Emotional distress refers to the psychological impact and mental suffering a person experiences following a traumatic event — such as a car accident.

Emotional Distress as a Legal Claim

In personal injury law, emotional distress is categorized as a non-economic damage. This means it doesn’t have a fixed cost like medical bills but can deeply affect your life.

Examples of qualifying emotional injuries include:

1. Constant anxiety or panic attacks
2. Nightmares or flashbacks
3. Sleep disturbances or chronic insomnia
4. Loss of appetite or interest in daily activities
5. Depression and emotional numbness

These symptoms are often referred to as “invisible injuries” — they may not be outwardly visible but are just as serious as physical injuries.

 

Can You Sue Without Physical Injuries?

Yes. Many people mistakenly believe they can’t file a lawsuit if they didn’t suffer a visible or physical injury during a car accident. This is not true.

Legal Recognition of Mental Harm

Courts now recognize that emotional trauma is a real consequence of motor vehicle accidents. Even if you weren’t hospitalized or didn’t break any bones, you can still pursue a claim if you can show:

• You experienced emotional trauma
• The trauma was severe and diagnosable
• It was directly caused by the accident

 

Common Types of Psychological Injuries That Qualify

Several psychological injuries may be considered legitimate bases for compensation after a car accident. The most common include:

1. Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

PTSD is a condition that results from traumatic experiences. It can cause you to relive the crash through nightmares, flashbacks, or heightened anxiety while driving.

2. Generalized Anxiety Disorder

This includes constant worry, restlessness, and tension — especially if it interferes with your ability to function at work or in relationships.

3. Depression

Emotional numbness, fatigue, and withdrawal from social activities may all point to depression brought on by the trauma of a crash.

4. Driving Phobia or Travel Avoidance

A fear of driving or riding in vehicles again is common and may require therapy to overcome.

5. Adjustment Disorders

Even without a formal PTSD or depression diagnosis, many people experience significant emotional adjustment difficulties after a serious accident.

 

How Do You Prove Emotional Distress in Court?

Proving emotional distress is more complex than proving a broken bone, but it’s possible with solid documentation.

What the Court Wants to See

Courts want to know that your emotional injuries are real, significant, and related to the accident. The best way to show this is through:

1. Therapy records from licensed professionals
2. Medical evidence, such as psychiatric prescriptions
3. Expert witness testimony from mental health experts
4. Personal journals documenting emotional effects
5. Statements from friends or family who noticed changes in your behavior

Key Tip

Start documenting symptoms as soon as they arise. Early and consistent treatment strengthens your case and shows that your suffering is legitimate and ongoing.

 

The Role of Therapy Records and Expert Testimony

Therapy records are the foundation of most emotional distress lawsuits. They not only document your condition but also track your recovery (or lack thereof).

Why These Records Matter

Insurance companies and courts see therapy as proactive treatment. It shows:

• You took your suffering seriously
• Your symptoms were severe enough to require professional care
• The trauma has impacted your everyday life

Expert Testimony Adds Authority

In more serious cases, your attorney may call a psychologist or psychiatrist to testify. These experts can explain:

• How your trauma matches diagnostic criteria (like PTSD)
• How your condition affects your job or relationships
• That the accident was likely the cause of your distress

 

How Much Compensation Can You Receive?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but courts do award damages for emotional distress — often in significant amounts.

Factors That Influence Settlement Amounts

The final payout depends on:

1. The severity of your symptoms
2. Whether your condition is medically diagnosed
3. How long your symptoms last
4. How the trauma affects your ability to work or function
5. The strength of your supporting documentation

Average Settlement Ranges

• Mild to moderate cases: $15,000 – $50,000
• PTSD or long-term cases: $50,000 – $100,000+
• Cases involving permanent disability or psychological breakdowns: Even higher

 

Steps to File an Emotional Distress Lawsuit After a Car Accident

If you’re ready to take legal action, here’s how the process generally works:

Step 1: Speak to a Personal Injury Lawyer

Choose a lawyer who specializes in emotional or non-physical injury cases. They’ll evaluate your claim and let you know if you have a strong case.

Step 2: Collect All Relevant Documentation

Gather therapy records, doctor’s notes, journals, witness statements, and any receipts related to treatment.

Step 3: File the Lawsuit

Your lawyer will file a civil complaint with the appropriate court, outlining your emotional damages and evidence.

Step 4: Participate in Discovery

You and the opposing party will exchange evidence. This may involve answering questions under oath or undergoing independent psychological evaluation.

Step 5: Settle or Go to Trial

Many emotional distress claims are settled outside of court. However, if the insurer doesn’t offer fair compensation, your case may go to trial.

 

Common Problems Victims Face

Even with clear symptoms, victims often encounter difficulties:

1. Insurance denial of PTSD or anxiety claims
2. Delays in treatment due to financial or logistical reasons
3. Skepticism from others who can’t see “invisible” injuries
4. Stigma around mental health, making victims reluctant to seek help
5. Lack of legal knowledge about their rights

These are all reasons why hiring an experienced attorney and seeking mental health treatment early are essential steps.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue for emotional distress if I didn’t suffer any physical injuries in the car accident?
Yes, you can. While physical injuries are often easier to document, emotional distress claims are legally recognized in many states, especially when the psychological harm is diagnosed by a medical professional and clearly linked to the accident. Courts are increasingly open to awarding damages for non-physical injuries such as anxiety, depression, and PTSD resulting from traumatic events like car crashes.

How do I prove emotional distress in a car accident case?
To prove emotional distress, you need supporting documentation that shows the severity and origin of your emotional symptoms. This includes medical and therapy records, psychiatric evaluations, prescriptions for anxiety or depression medication, personal journals, and testimony from expert witnesses such as psychologists. Statements from people close to you who have observed changes in your behavior may also support your claim.

Is PTSD covered in car accident settlements?
Yes, PTSD is one of the most common psychological conditions resulting from car accidents and is frequently included in personal injury settlements. If you’ve been diagnosed with PTSD following a crash, and your symptoms are severe enough to interfere with daily life or work, your attorney can seek compensation for therapy costs, lost income, and emotional suffering.

Do I need a lawyer to file an emotional distress claim?
While it’s legally possible to file a claim on your own, having an experienced personal injury lawyer significantly improves your chances of success. Emotional distress cases can be complex, especially when proving psychological injuries without physical trauma. A lawyer can help collect the right evidence, bring in expert witnesses, negotiate with insurance companies, and file your claim correctly.

How much compensation can I get for emotional trauma after a car accident?
Compensation varies based on the severity of your symptoms, the evidence available, and how your condition affects your life. Settlements for mild emotional distress may range from $15,000 to $30,000, while cases involving PTSD or long-term therapy can exceed $100,000. The final amount depends on your medical documentation, expert testimony, and whether the case is settled or goes to trial.

 

Conclusion: Your Legal Rights Matter

Your emotional injuries matter. Just because they’re not visible doesn’t mean they don’t exist or deserve compensation. Anxiety, depression, and PTSD after a car crash can dramatically alter your quality of life — but the law recognizes your right to seek justice and recovery.

 

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., Today

If you’re suffering emotionally after a car accident, don’t suffer in silence. You may be entitled to compensation — and taking legal action could be the first step toward healing.

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., today to find out how to file an emotional distress claim and begin the journey to justice.