Video preview

When a perforation after surgery needs closer review

A perforation is an unintended hole or tear in the wall of an organ – bowel, bladder, stomach, or another structure – made during a procedure. Some perforations are spotted and repaired in the same operation and heal without lasting harm. Concern grows when the injury was not found, early symptoms were explained away, and the patient returned days later with a spreading abdominal infection. Our overview of New Jersey medical malpractice claims explains how these cases are assessed when that pattern sounds familiar.

This page follows one injury mechanism across many operations. A bowel perforation can complicate gallbladder removal, hysterectomy, colonoscopy, and other abdominal or pelvic procedures, and the legal questions repeat: how the injury happened, whether it should have been recognized sooner, and what the delay cost. For surgical error more generally, see our surgery malpractice page.

  • In the procedure room: Was the perforation seen and repaired, mentioned in the operative report, or nowhere recorded?
  • In the first days afterward: Were escalating pain, fever, a racing pulse, or a rigid abdomen reported – and how did the team respond?
  • At readmission: What did imaging show, when was repair surgery performed, and what did the second operative report describe?

Those questions organize a review; they do not decide it. Some perforations are recognized complications of difficult procedures; separating those from a preventable injury or a missed diagnosis takes the records and a qualified expert.

Sources: NJ Courts: Medical negligence—duty and negligence; AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research.

The Epstein Law Firm

Questions after a perforated organ injury?

Punctured organ injury claims in New Jersey

Unmarked laparoscopic instruments on a sterile operating room tray

Tell us what procedure was performed, when the perforation was found, and what treatment followed. We can discuss the next steps in reviewing a potential claim.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Schedule your free case evaluation

Perforation failures a case review may examine

How the injury happened

In laparoscopic surgery, instruments and trocars are placed through small incisions, with the surgeon working from a camera image and a narrow field of view. A review can examine instrument handling and visualization – for example, a bowel injury during gallbladder removal, a bladder injury during hysterectomy, or a tear made during colonoscopy. Where the view or anatomy made the approach unsafe, a review may also ask whether the surgeon should have converted to open surgery rather than pressing on.

A perforation that was never checked for

Before closing, a surgeon who suspects an organ injury is expected to inspect the area. A review may examine whether the field was checked, whether inspection steps appropriate to the procedure were used, and whether the operative report matches what the repair surgeon later discovered. An injury that reasonable inspection would have revealed, left unclosed, is a different matter from one that genuinely could not be seen.

Warning signs answered too slowly

The most damaging failures are often after the procedure. Leaking bowel or bladder contents can progress to peritonitis and sepsis. A review can examine whether post-operative warning signs – pain out of proportion to the operation, fever, rapid heartbeat, vomiting, a hard or swelling abdomen – prompted timely imaging and consultation, or were attributed to normal recovery while the patient deteriorated.

Repair and follow-through

Once a perforation is found, the response matters: how quickly repair surgery followed, whether the repair held, and whether complications such as abscess or fistula were managed, and whether a temporary or permanent ostomy was needed while the bowel heals. A review covers that downstream care as well; the consequences of delay are measured in the treatment it made necessary.

Sources: AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research; CDC: Healthcare-associated infections data and prevention.

What to do when you suspect an organ was perforated

Treat the medical problem first, and urgently: worsening abdominal pain, fever, vomiting, or a racing heartbeat after a procedure can signal a leak and warrants emergency evaluation, not a wait for a legal opinion.

  1. Build a symptom timeline. Write down when symptoms began, every call or visit where you reported them, what you were told, and when imaging or readmission finally happened. In these cases, this chronology is often the heart of the dispute.
  2. Request the records from both episodes. Ask for the original operative report, imaging and radiology reports – especially any CT scan – readmission notes, the repair report, and discharge instructions from each stay.
  3. Preserve the documents around the injury. Keep bills, insurer statements, and work records in original form, including paperwork for ostomy supplies or home care.
  4. Note who treated you where. The surgeon, hospital, and repair team may hold separate charts; list each one so nothing is overlooked.

The two operative reports are read against each other: what the first says about inspection and findings, set beside what the repair surgeon found, often shows whether the injury was visible all along. Timestamps in nursing notes then test how quickly the team moved once symptoms appeared.

Sources: HHS: HIPAA right of access to health information; NJ Courts: Medical negligence—duty and negligence.

What New Jersey requires in a punctured organ case

A perforation claim must connect four things with evidence: the standard of care for the procedure, a breach of it, causation, and damages. Expert testimony from a qualified practitioner in the relevant field ordinarily carries the standard-of-care and causation questions – including what earlier recognition would have changed.

The discovery rule has particular force here, because a perforation is often diagnosed days after the procedure, sometimes at a different hospital. New Jersey’s two-year limitations period in N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2 generally runs from accrual, and accrual can turn on when the patient knew or reasonably should have known of the injury and its possible link to the procedure.

New Jersey also requires expert screening. Under the Affidavit of Merit statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27, the plaintiff must serve an affidavit from an appropriately qualified expert attesting to a reasonable probability that the care departed from acceptable standards. The deadline is 60 days after the defendant’s answer, with a single court-granted extension of up to 60 more days available for good cause. It is a procedural gate, separate from winning at trial, and missing it can bring dismissal.

Fault and forum complete the framework. New Jersey’s comparative negligence law, N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, reduces an award by any share of fault attributed to the patient and bars recovery if that share is greater than 50 percent. Compensatory damages in New Jersey medical malpractice cases are not subject to a statutory cap. One exception applies: claims against nonprofit hospitals are capped at $250,000 under the charitable immunity statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-8. If the procedure was at a public facility, the Tort Claims Act, N.J.S.A. 59:8-8, ordinarily requires notice within 90 days – a deadline that can expire during recovery from repair surgery.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27: New Jersey affidavit of merit statute; N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2: New Jersey personal injury limitations period; New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information.

The Epstein Law Firm

Get the procedure and hospital timeline reviewed

Punctured organ injury claims in New Jersey

Unmarked laparoscopic instruments on a sterile operating room tray

Imaging, operative notes, and post-operative charts can show when a perforation should have been recognized. Start with the procedure date, facility, and the records you already have.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Schedule your free case evaluation

Documenting the full impact of a perforation injury

The losses in a perforation case are driven largely by timing: an injury repaired in the same operation may mean a longer recovery and little more, while the same injury found three days later can mean emergency surgery, intensive care, and months of consequences.

  • Emergency and repair care: Readmission, repair operations, intensive care, and treatment of sepsis or abscess that earlier recognition might have avoided.
  • Future treatment: Medically supported expectations such as ostomy care and supplies, a possible reversal operation, and monitoring for complications.
  • Work and earnings: Time lost during the extended recovery and any lasting limits on earning ability, shown with employment records.
  • Pain and daily life: The pain of peritonitis and repeat surgery, dietary restrictions, and the effect of an ostomy on ordinary life, described concretely.
  • Family impact: Caregiving and household help the family provided through a recovery far longer than the original procedure promised.

Keep the originals of bills and records even where insurance covered part of the cost. Reimbursement obligations can change what a recovery means in practice, and complete paperwork makes the accounting far easier.

Sources: NJ Courts: Medical expenses; NJ Courts: Future medical expenses; NJ Courts: Loss of earnings; NJ Courts: Disability, impairment, and pain and suffering.

Why consider The Epstein Law Firm for a punctured organ claim?

A perforation case may require a lawyer to organize two episodes of care into one chronology, work with appropriately qualified experts, and explain the evidence clearly. The firm’s published attorney biographies identify the experience and qualifications behind that work.

Civil trial certification and medical malpractice experience

Barry D. Epstein’s biography lists medical malpractice among his practice areas and identifies his certification by the Supreme Court of New Jersey as a Civil Trial Attorney beginning in 1984. Michael J. Epstein’s biography also lists medical malpractice and Civil Trial Attorney certification. Those are civil-trial credentials; they are not medical qualifications or a guarantee that a particular claim will succeed.

Teaching, writing, and professional leadership

Barry Epstein’s biography documents two 1990 Institute for Continuing Legal Education presentations titled “How to Try a Medical Malpractice Case” and service as a Tort Law Conference moderator and speaker from 2006 through 2018. It also records his New Jersey State Bar Association presidency in 2000–2001.

Michael Epstein’s biography identifies his authorship of the Bergen County Bar Association’s monthly Civil Practice Update and his service as that association’s president in 2016–2017. This background gives a prospective client specific experience to discuss at a consultation: who will evaluate the records, how expert qualifications will be checked, and how the firm would develop the evidence.

Recognition in context

Barry Epstein’s biography lists selection to the Top 100 New Jersey Super Lawyers list for 2005–2016, 2018, and 2020. These are historical selections attributed to the individual attorney, not a case success rate for any single type of claim. No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey. Results depend on the facts and law applicable to each case.

Sources: The Epstein Law Firm: Barry D. Epstein biography; The Epstein Law Firm: Michael J. Epstein biography; The Epstein Law Firm: Rating methodology.

The firm offers a free initial consultation. Its Rochelle Park office is at 340 West Passaic Street, Rochelle Park NJ 07662. Call (201) 231-7847 or use the contact page to discuss the procedure, the injury, and whether further review is appropriate.

Sources: The Epstein Law Firm: Contact and office information; The Epstein Law Firm: Medical malpractice representation.

Notable Results

Selected firm results, including medical-care cases. The confidential firm-wide result is not identified as a punctured-organ case.

$13.585 Million · $1.5 Million · $500,000

$13.585 Million — Confidential Settlement

Firm-wide result

The firm lists a $13.585 million confidential settlement. The case type is not disclosed.

$1.5 Million — Jury Verdict

Medical care

A jury verdict obtained on behalf of a husband and wife against doctors for injuries to the husband’s genitalia.

$500,000 — Settlement

Post-operative monitoring

A settlement for a man who was in a coma after doctors failed to monitor him properly following an operation.

View all verdicts and settlements →

These are selected firm results, not representations of punctured-organ-specific outcomes. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case must be evaluated on its own facts.

What Our Clients Say

“They took the time to explain everything clearly, making sure I understood my options and felt comfortable with each step of the process.”

“Michael and his team were incredibly responsive, always keeping us informed and addressing any questions or concerns promptly.”

Meet The Epstein Law Firm

The Epstein Law Firm

Talk with us about what happens next

Punctured organ injury claims in New Jersey

Unmarked laparoscopic instruments on a sterile operating room tray

You do not need to sort out the medical explanation on your own before asking for a consultation. Bring your questions and the information currently available to you.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Schedule your free case evaluation

New Jersey Punctured Organ Injury FAQs: Perforation, Delayed Diagnosis, and Your Claim

These answers provide general information about New Jersey punctured organ injury claims. They are not legal advice or an assessment of an individual case.

How long do I have to file a punctured organ claim in New Jersey?

Ordinarily two years under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2, New Jersey’s personal-injury limitations statute. Perforation cases raise a timing wrinkle: the injury is often discovered days after the procedure, sometimes during a readmission elsewhere, so the discovery rule can affect when the period begins – when you knew, or reasonably should have known, of the injury and its link to the procedure.

Because that start date is fact-specific, do not rely on the procedure date or the discovery date without advice. Tell the lawyer both dates, plus where each episode of care occurred. If a public facility was involved, a separate 90-day notice deadline may apply and can expire first.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2: New Jersey personal injury limitations period; N.J.S.A. 59:8-8: New Jersey Tort Claims Act notice deadline

Is every perforated organ during surgery considered malpractice in New Jersey?

No. Perforation is a recognized risk of many abdominal and pelvic procedures, and it can happen even when the surgeon uses accepted technique – in dense scar tissue or distorted anatomy, for example. A poor outcome from a known risk, without more, does not establish negligence under New Jersey law.

The questions that separate a complication from a claim are how the injury occurred, whether it should have been seen and repaired before closing, and how the team responded once symptoms appeared. A perforation caused by careless technique, one that reasonable checks would have caught, or one whose warning signs were ignored for days presents a different review.

Sources: AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research; New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information

Why does New Jersey require an expert affidavit for a perforation claim?

New Jersey uses the affidavit of merit, required by N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27, to screen malpractice cases early. An appropriately qualified expert must swear there is a reasonable probability the care departed from acceptable standards. For a perforation claim, that expert addresses whether the injury or its delayed recognition fell below the standard and whether earlier action would likely have changed the outcome.

The affidavit is generally due within 60 days after the defendant answers the complaint, with one court-granted extension of up to 60 days possible for good cause. It does not decide the case; the claim must still be proved. Expert review must therefore happen early.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27: New Jersey affidavit of merit statute; New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information

Can a bowel perforation missed after gallbladder surgery support a claim?

It can, depending on what the records show. The gallbladder sits close to the bowel, and laparoscopic removal is one setting where an unrecognized bowel injury can occur. A review examines the operative report, the post-operative notes for escalating pain, fever, or a rising pulse, and the timing of imaging and readmission.

The delay is usually the issue that drives harm: bowel contents leaking into the abdomen can progress to peritonitis and sepsis, turning a repairable injury into emergency surgery and intensive care. Notes, scan timestamps, and the repair surgeon’s findings together show whether recognition came as quickly as the symptoms required.

Sources: AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research; CDC: Healthcare-associated infections data and prevention

What warning signs after surgery can point to an unrecognized perforation?

Warning signs can include abdominal pain that worsens instead of easing, fever, a rapid heartbeat, nausea or vomiting, a swollen or rigid abdomen, and feeling sicker each day rather than recovering. After a perforation, leaking contents irritate the abdominal cavity, and infection can develop into peritonitis or sepsis if the leak is not found and treated.

If you are experiencing symptoms like these after a procedure, seek emergency medical care immediately; this page is general information, not medical advice. For a later legal review, write down when each symptom began and what response each report received. That chronology, matched against the chart, is how a delayed-recognition claim is evaluated.

Sources: CDC: Healthcare-associated infections data and prevention; AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research

Preserve every version of the consent documents and note what was actually discussed. Whether the injury, the failure to detect it, or the response breached the standard of care is an expert question; the form is evidence in that review, not a release from it.

Sources: New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information; New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: Consumer information

Can a perforation during a colonoscopy support a malpractice claim in New Jersey?

It can, in the right circumstances. Colonoscopy carries a known perforation risk, particularly where polyps are removed, so the occurrence alone does not prove negligence. A review looks at technique, the difficulty documented in the procedure report, whether the tear was seen during the examination, and how post-procedure pain was handled.

Some colonoscopy perforations are closed during the procedure itself with clips; others need surgery, and the harm often tracks how quickly the problem was identified. Keep the procedure report, discharge instructions, and records of any emergency visit that followed.

Sources: AHRQ: Patient safety resources and research; New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information

What records help prove a delayed perforation diagnosis?

The core records are the original operative or procedure report, nursing and progress notes from the days that followed, imaging orders and radiology reports – above all any CT scan – and the readmission and repair-surgery records. Read together, they show what symptoms were documented, when a scan was finally ordered, and what the repair surgeon found.

Add your own dated account of symptoms and of each call or visit where you reported them, and keep bills and discharge papers from every facility involved, since care often spans two hospitals. If a chart seems incomplete, note what you requested and when.

Sources: New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information; New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: Consumer information

Can I recover for repair surgery or an ostomy after a perforation in New Jersey?

Yes, where the underlying claim is supported, those consequences are part of the damages. Repair operations, intensive care, and treatment of infection are medical losses to be proved with records and bills. An ostomy – temporary or permanent – carries its own costs, supplies, possible reversal surgery, and a real effect on daily life that should be documented concretely.

Future needs must rest on a medical prognosis rather than speculation, and experts may be needed to quantify long-term care and earning effects. New Jersey law also applies its comparative negligence rule to the overall recovery, reducing it by any proved share of patient fault and barring recovery if that share exceeds 50 percent.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1: New Jersey comparative negligence rule; New Jersey Courts: Civil Division information

What if my family member died after an unrecognized organ perforation?

New Jersey’s wrongful death statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:31-1, allows a claim on behalf of surviving family members when a death is caused by a wrongful act or neglect that would have supported the patient’s own claim had the patient lived. In a perforation case, that means examining the original injury and, often more importantly, the days in which warning signs went unanswered.

These claims have their own rules about who may bring them and what losses are recoverable, and the same filing deadlines and expert requirements apply, so early review matters. Gather the procedure and readmission records and the death certificate, and note the family’s account of symptoms reported before the death.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:31-1: New Jersey wrongful death statute; N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2: New Jersey personal injury limitations period

Related Articles

Related Epstein Law Firm Videos and Social Posts