What to Do If the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance Denies Your Claim

All Practice Areas

When you’re involved in a car accident and it’s clear that the other driver is at fault, you naturally expect their insurance company to pay for your damages. That expectation, unfortunately, doesn’t always align with reality. Many accident victims find themselves in a frustrating situation where the at-fault driver’s insurer denies the claim entirely.

The shock and confusion that follow are understandable. After all, if you’re not to blame, why should you be the one left footing the bill?

A Common But Frustrating Reality

Insurance companies deny claims for a variety of reasons — some of which may be legitimate, others less so. In many cases, these denials are driven by efforts to reduce payouts or avoid liability altogether.

Knowing why your claim was denied and what legal options are available can be the difference between accepting a loss and getting the compensation you deserve.

This guide will walk you through what to do if your car accident claim is denied by the at-fault driver’s insurance company. You’ll learn why claims get denied, what steps to take, and how to pursue a successful appeal or legal resolution.

Why the At-Fault Driver’s Insurer Might Deny Your Claim

Even when the facts of the accident clearly show that the other driver was responsible, insurance companies often find reasons to reject third-party claims.

Liability Disputes

One of the most common reasons is a dispute over liability. The insurance adjuster may claim that you were partially or even fully at fault. In states with comparative negligence laws, even a small percentage of shared fault can significantly reduce or eliminate their payout obligations.

Insufficient Evidence

Insurers may also deny a claim based on what they perceive as insufficient supporting evidence. If you didn’t take photos, gather witness information, or file a police report, they may argue there’s no proof the other driver caused the accident.

Policy Exclusions and Technicalities

Sometimes the claim is denied due to policy exclusions, such as when the at-fault driver wasn’t covered while operating the vehicle. Filing delays, administrative errors, or even paperwork mistakes may also be used as grounds for rejection.

Bad Faith Tactics

In some cases, these denial strategies cross into bad faith territory — a legal term that refers to insurers acting dishonestly or unfairly to avoid paying valid claims.

Understanding Your Legal Rights After a Claim Denial

You have legal rights that protect you against unfair insurance claim denials. All insurers are required by law to act in good faith, meaning they must handle claims fairly, promptly, and honestly.

What Good Faith Means

Good faith includes conducting thorough investigations, providing timely updates, and offering fair compensation based on the facts of the case. If your insurer doesn’t follow these obligations, you may have grounds to file a bad faith claim against them.

Recognizing Bad Faith Behavior

Examples of bad faith practices include refusing to properly investigate the accident, misrepresenting policy terms, offering an unjustifiably low settlement, or ignoring your claim altogether. These are not just unethical — they’re potentially illegal.

Immediate Steps to Take After a Claim Denial

Receiving a denial letter can feel like the end of the road, but it’s actually where your options begin. Here’s how to respond effectively.

Step One: Review the Denial Letter

Start by carefully reading the denial letter. Insurance companies are required to provide specific reasons for the denial. Understanding their rationale is critical to forming your next steps.

Step Two: Organize Documentation

Gather all evidence related to your accident. This includes the police report, medical records, repair estimates, witness statements, and photographs. Strong documentation can expose flaws in the insurer’s reasoning.

Step Three: Request Clarification

If the insurer’s explanation is vague or unclear, ask for a more detailed response in writing. You have a right to understand their decision-making process.

Step Four: Send a Demand Letter

A demand letter is a formal written request asking the insurer to reconsider the claim. It should clearly state your version of events, include all evidence, and outline the financial compensation you’re seeking.

Step Five: Consult a Lawyer

If you’re not comfortable handling this on your own, speak with a car accident lawyer. Many attorneys offer free consultations and can tell you immediately if the denial violates the law.

Appealing or Fighting the Denial

If your demand letter and documentation don’t result in a reversal, the next step is to formally appeal the denial or file a complaint.

How to Write a Claim Denial Response

Your response should be clear, direct, and backed by evidence. It should restate your claim, challenge the denial point-by-point, and request a fair reassessment. Make sure it’s professionally written and sent via certified mail.

Filing a Complaint with State Regulators

Each state has a Department of Insurance that regulates how insurers handle claims. Filing a complaint can initiate a regulatory investigation and often prompts a more serious response from the insurer.

Legal Action as a Final Option

If the insurer still refuses to act in good faith, you may need to file a lawsuit. While this may sound intimidating, many personal injury and insurance lawyers work on a contingency fee basis — they only get paid if you win.

When Legal Action Becomes Necessary

Sometimes, legal action is the only way to get the compensation you’re owed. This is especially true if the insurer is acting in bad faith or if your financial damages are significant.

Weighing the Costs and Benefits

Pursuing a lawsuit takes time, but it can result in a full recovery of your damages, including medical bills, vehicle repairs, and even punitive damages if the insurer’s behavior was especially egregious. If you have significant financial losses or permanent injuries, legal action is not only worth considering — it may be your best option.

What If the At-Fault Driver Has No Insurance?

If the at-fault driver doesn’t have insurance, or their policy limits are too low to cover your losses, you may still be protected under your own policy.

Using Your Own Coverage

Uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage (UM/UIM) allows you to file a claim with your own insurer. This can help pay for medical expenses, car repairs, and more. However, your own insurer may still push back, so it’s important to treat this process just as seriously.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still get compensation if the other driver’s insurance denies my claim?
Yes, even if the at-fault driver’s insurer denies your claim, you still have several options for seeking compensation. You may appeal the denial directly with the insurance company, file a complaint with your state’s insurance department, or initiate a lawsuit against the at-fault driver or the insurer. If you carry uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, you may also be able to file a claim through your own insurance policy to recover damages.

Is it legal for an insurance company to deny a claim?
Insurance companies are legally allowed to deny claims, but only if they have valid, well-documented reasons for doing so. A denial must be based on clear policy terms, legitimate liability disputes, or other substantiated grounds. If a claim is denied without a reasonable investigation, or if the insurer provides vague or contradictory explanations, that denial may be unlawful and considered bad faith, which could entitle you to additional compensation.

What if the at-fault driver has no insurance?
If the other driver does not carry insurance or doesn’t have enough coverage to pay for your damages, you may need to rely on your own policy. Uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, which is optional in some states and required in others, is designed specifically for these situations. Filing a claim under this coverage can help pay for your medical expenses, car repairs, and other losses, though your own insurer may still scrutinize your claim.

How do I respond to a denial letter from the insurance company? 

You should respond to a denial letter by reviewing it carefully, gathering documentation that supports your claim, and submitting a formal response or demand letter. In your letter, clearly state why you believe the denial was incorrect, reference specific facts from the accident, and attach evidence such as photos, medical records, and police reports. If the denial was vague, you can also request further clarification. Sending your response via certified mail ensures you have a record of the communication.

Should I hire a lawyer if my car accident claim is denied?
Yes, in most cases, it’s wise to consult a lawyer if your claim has been denied — especially if you’re facing serious injuries, significant vehicle damage, or uncooperative insurers. A personal injury attorney can help determine whether the denial was made in bad faith, negotiate directly with the insurer on your behalf, and file a lawsuit if necessary. Many lawyers offer free consultations and work on a contingency fee basis, so there’s no upfront cost unless you win your case.

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., Today

If your car accident claim has been denied by the at-fault driver’s insurance company, don’t navigate the system alone. A qualified personal injury or insurance attorney can assess your situation, explain your legal options, and help you pursue the compensation you deserve.

We offer free consultations and only charge if they win your case. You’ve already been through the trauma of the accident — you don’t need to battle the insurance company on your own, too. Reach out to The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., today and take the first step toward justice and peace of mind.