Injured in an Uber Accident – Who Is Liable?

All Practice Areas

With the rapid growth of ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft, the landscape of personal injury law in New Jersey has evolved significantly. Understanding who is at fault in accidents involving these services can be complex, especially given the state’s specific legal intricacies.

At The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., we specialize in navigating this complex field and providing essential guidance to both passengers and drivers affected by such incidents. This guide offers an in-depth look at the laws and cases shaping ride-sharing accident liability in New Jersey.

What is Ride-Sharing Accident Liability in New Jersey?

Understanding who is at fault in accidents involving ride-sharing services can be complex due to the unique operational model of companies like Uber and Lyft, which classify their drivers as independent contractors. The state of New Jersey has also implemented specific laws to address these modern transportation challenges, further complicating liability determinations. For a comprehensive overview, explore our legal guide to Uber and Lyft accident liability in New Jersey.

How is liability determined in New Jersey ride-sharing accidents?

Determining fault and liability in a ride-sharing accident involves analyzing whether the driver was operating under their personal capacity or engaged with the ride-sharing platform. This distinction is critical because it dictates which insurance policy—personal or corporate—will be primary.

What is individual liability for Uber and Lyft drivers?

• Independent Contractor Status: Uber and Lyft classify their drivers as independent contractors, not employees. This classification significantly impacts liability coverage.
• Personal Auto Insurance: When drivers are not engaged in a ride (i.e., when the app is off or they’re not transporting a passenger), any accident they might cause is generally covered by their personal auto insurance policy.

What is corporate liability for Uber and Lyft in New Jersey?

Both Uber and Lyft implement a tiered insurance policy. This means that from the moment a driver logs into the app to wait for a ride request, the company provides a certain level of liability coverage. This coverage substantially increases once a passenger is in the vehicle. If an Uber or Lyft accident occurs during this time, the company’s insurance is likely to cover damages. However, exceptions and specific policy details do apply, making understanding the specifics of this coverage crucial. For more details on these policies, read about Uber and Lyft insurance policies for NJ accidents. You may also wonder, will Uber compensate you for an accident?

What is New Jersey’s legal framework for ride-sharing accidents?

In 2017, New Jersey implemented the Transportation Network Company Safety and Regulatory Act to address the concerns arising from the proliferation of ride-sharing platforms. This act provides clear guidelines and stipulations concerning the operation of ride-sharing companies in the state.

What is the Transportation Network Company Safety and Regulatory Act of 2017?

The Act includes several key provisions:

• Minimum Insurance Requirements: The law mandates specific insurance requirements for different stages of the ride-sharing process.
  • When the driver has the ride-sharing app turned on but hasn’t accepted a ride request, they must have a minimum of $50,000 for death and injury per person, $100,000 for death and injury per incident, and $25,000 for property damage.
  • The coverage escalates significantly once a ride request is accepted and continues until the passenger exits the vehicle. During this period, the driver or the ride-sharing company must provide a combined single limit of $1.5 million for deaths, personal injuries, and property damage. Additionally, there should be $1.5 million in uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.
• Driver Responsibilities: Drivers are required to maintain their personal auto insurance. If a driver’s insurance policy doesn’t meet the state’s requirements, the ride-sharing company’s insurance is obligated to provide coverage starting from the first dollar of a claim. For comprehensive details, see our article on what are the Uber and Lyft insurance policies for NJ accidents.
• Background Checks: The act mandates ride-sharing companies to conduct thorough background checks for their drivers. These checks include multi-state criminal background checks, a full driving history report, and a check on the National Sex Offender Registry. Drivers with convictions of certain offenses within the past seven years, such as DUI, fraud, sexual offenses, or acts of violence, are barred from driving for ride-sharing platforms.
• Vehicle Inspections: All vehicles used in ride-sharing must undergo inspections at least once every two years to ensure they comply with safety standards.
• Ride Sharing Identification: Vehicles engaged in ride-sharing must display an identifying marker, usually provided by the ride-sharing company, to ensure they’re easily recognizable.
• Consumer Protections: The act also addresses transparency in fare pricing, the need for electronic receipts, and provisions that prohibit discrimination against riders based on their destination, race, age, sexual orientation, or any other protected status.

New Jersey’s laws related to ride-sharing prioritize the safety and rights of drivers and passengers alike, ensuring operations meet specific standards to minimize potential liabilities and disputes.

What are common ride-sharing accident liability case studies in New Jersey?

Ride-sharing accidents in New Jersey have given rise to numerous lawsuits, with varying outcomes. Understanding these real-life examples can clarify how liability is often determined.

What happens if an “on the clock” Uber driver, without a passenger, causes an accident?

In a significant New Jersey case, an Uber driver, actively logged into the app and waiting for a ride request, was involved in an accident between rides. The driver argued that since he was technically “on the clock,” Uber’s insurance should cover the damages. This case tested the boundaries of when corporate insurance kicks in, given Uber’s tiered policy with different coverage levels depending on the driver’s status. The resolution provided the driver with some coverage from Uber’s insurance, highlighting the complexities of the “app on but no passenger” scenarios. This further underscores the question: will Uber compensate you for an accident in such situations?

Who is liable when a third-party driver causes an Uber or Lyft accident?

In another Uber accident case, a vehicle with a passenger was struck by a third-party driver not affiliated with any ride-sharing platform. Here, determining liability was more straightforward; the third-party driver’s insurance was deemed responsible for covering the damages, as they were at fault for the accident. This case demonstrated that even within the context of ride-sharing, traditional traffic laws and liabilities remain applicable.

Can Uber or Lyft be held liable for driver assault or misconduct?

A more contentious case involved an Uber passenger who was assaulted by their driver. While the driver was clearly at fault for the assault, the legal debate focused on Uber’s potential negligence in its screening process. The victim claimed Uber did not take enough precautions to ensure passenger safety. This case spotlighted the importance of comprehensive background checks and the ride-sharing platform’s responsibility in ensuring the safety of its users. The resolution leaned toward holding ride-sharing platforms more accountable for their drivers’ actions. If you are considering filing a lawsuit against a rideshare driver in New Jersey, or wondering can you sue Uber and Lyft after an accident in New Jersey, this type of case is highly relevant.

What is the liability for passenger injury after an unsafe early exit from a ride-share?

In a unique scenario, a Lyft passenger requested an early exit from the vehicle in an unsafe location, leading to an accident shortly after they exited. While the initial claim targeted the Lyft driver for permitting the passenger to disembark unsafely, the complexity arose over whether the passenger bore any responsibility for their own decision. The case underscored the nuances of determining fault, particularly when both parties might share some responsibility. If you’re involved in such a situation, it’s crucial to understand the steps to take if your Uber or Lyft driver causes an accident in New Jersey.

How can The Epstein Law Firm, P.A. assist with ride-sharing accident cases?

Navigating the maze of liability in ride-sharing accidents in New Jersey requires an adept understanding of both state regulations and the specific policies of companies like Uber and Lyft. Both drivers and passengers should be aware of their rights and the potential avenues of liability in the unfortunate event of an accident. When facing these challenges, knowing how to choose the right lawyer for a rideshare accident case in New Jersey is paramount.

If you or a loved one have been involved in a ridesharing accident and are unsure about your legal position, don’t hesitate. Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A. today. Our experienced team is ready to offer guidance and pursue the justice you deserve.