How Much Is a Brain Injury Case Worth After a Car Crash?

All Practice Areas

Brain injuries resulting from car accidents are among the most serious—and costly—types of personal injury cases. While some head injuries may appear mild at first, they can evolve into long-term neurological problems, affecting memory, mood, and even a person’s ability to work or care for themselves. Unlike broken bones or visible wounds, brain injuries often go undetected at first, yet they can carry lifelong consequences.

In this guide, we’ll examine how brain injury settlements are calculated, what factors affect the value of a traumatic brain injury (TBI) lawsuit, and what victims can do to ensure they receive the full compensation they deserve.

 

Types of Brain Injuries Caused by Car Accidents

Car accidents are one of the most common causes of traumatic brain injuries (TBIs). The impact of a collision can force the brain to move rapidly inside the skull, causing damage to brain tissue, nerves, or blood vessels. The type of brain injury sustained plays a major role in the value of the personal injury claim.

Mild Traumatic Brain Injury (mTBI)

A mild TBI, often referred to as a concussion, can result from even low-speed collisions. Victims may suffer from headaches, dizziness, memory problems, and sensitivity to light or sound. Though symptoms may seem minor, they can linger for weeks or months. In some cases, victims later develop post-concussion syndrome, which requires long-term treatment.

Moderate to Severe TBI

These injuries involve loss of consciousness for several minutes or longer and often require emergency treatment or hospitalization. Victims may experience cognitive difficulties, emotional instability, speech problems, and permanent physical limitations. These injuries are life-changing and typically result in higher settlement values due to their long-term impact.

Diffuse Axonal Injury (DAI)

DAIs are one of the most serious types of TBIs and occur when the brain shifts rapidly inside the skull, tearing brain tissue. Victims may fall into a coma and often suffer long-term impairments. Because these injuries are severe and often permanent, they typically result in substantial compensation awards.

 

How Brain Injury Settlements Are Calculated

Determining the value of a brain injury claim requires an in-depth analysis of both economic and non-economic damages. Insurance companies and juries will consider the full impact of the injury on the victim’s life, now and in the future.

Medical Evidence and Documentation

Strong medical documentation is the foundation of any brain injury claim. This includes:

1. Emergency room and hospital records
2. CT scans and MRI imaging results
3. Neurological and neuropsychological evaluations
4. Progress reports from specialists, such as neurologists and psychologists

Proper documentation not only proves the injury occurred but also connects it directly to the car accident. Without a clear diagnosis and paper trail, insurance companies may downplay the severity of the injury.

Long-Term Medical Costs and Treatment

Brain injuries often require long-term or even lifelong treatment. These future costs must be included in a settlement or verdict. Common long-term expenses include:

1. Occupational and physical therapy
2. Speech and language therapy
3. Psychiatric care and medication
4. Assistive devices and home modifications
5. In-home or residential care

An experienced attorney will work with medical and financial experts to calculate the lifetime cost of care.

Lost Wages and Earning Potential

A brain injury can prevent a person from working temporarily—or permanently. If the victim is unable to return to their job or has to take a lower-paying position due to cognitive limitations, they may be entitled to compensation for:

1. Past lost wages
2. Future loss of earning capacity
3. Missed career opportunities or promotions
4. Loss of business income (if self-employed)

These calculations are especially important for younger victims who may face decades of reduced income.

Pain and Suffering

Pain and suffering damages are awarded for the non-economic impact of a brain injury. This includes:

1. Chronic headaches or migraines
2. Emotional trauma and anxiety
3. Depression and mood disorders
4. Cognitive confusion or memory loss
5. Loss of enjoyment of life
6. Relationship and family strain

Because pain and suffering are subjective, skilled legal representation is essential to demonstrate the depth of the impact to a jury or insurance adjuster.

 

Legal Factors That Affect the Value of a TBI Case

While medical facts carry significant weight, the legal process itself also influences the outcome of a brain injury case. Below are some key legal considerations that may increase or decrease the final settlement or verdict.

Liability and Fault

If the other driver is clearly at fault, the victim may be eligible for full compensation. However, if there is shared liability—for example, if the injured person was speeding or not wearing a seatbelt—the settlement may be reduced.

Many states follow comparative negligence rules. This means that your percentage of fault will reduce the total compensation. In some states, if you’re more than 50% at fault, you may not be able to recover damages at all.

Insurance Policy Limits

Even in severe injury cases, compensation may be limited by the at-fault driver’s insurance policy. If their liability coverage caps at $100,000, but your medical bills and lost wages exceed that amount, your lawyer may need to:

• Seek compensation from your own underinsured motorist policy
• File a lawsuit against the driver’s personal assets
• Explore other liable parties (e.g., employers or manufacturers)

Jury Sentiment and Trial Outcomes

Brain injuries are sometimes invisible to the naked eye, which can make convincing a jury difficult. However, strong medical evidence, compelling expert testimony, and personal stories from loved ones can help demonstrate the true impact of the injury.

Some jurisdictions are more plaintiff-friendly than others, meaning juries are more likely to award larger settlements. Your attorney should be familiar with the tendencies of local courts and adjust your legal strategy accordingly.

 

What Is the Average Settlement for a Brain Injury Case?

Brain injury settlements vary widely depending on the type and severity of the injury, as well as the evidence available and the skill of the attorney representing the victim.

Here are some general ranges:

• Mild TBI or concussion: $50,000 – $200,000
• Moderate TBI: $200,000 – $750,000
• Severe or permanent TBI: $750,000 – $3 million or more
• Cases involving permanent cognitive loss or coma: $3 million – $10 million+

Keep in mind, these are averages. Some cases settle for less, especially when evidence is limited. Others result in multimillion-dollar jury verdicts when the injury is catastrophic and life-altering.

 

How to Strengthen Your Brain Injury Claim

To improve your chances of securing fair compensation:

1. Seek medical treatment immediately after the accident
2. Follow all recommended treatment plans
3. Document all symptoms, no matter how minor
4. Keep a daily journal of how your injury affects daily life
5. Avoid posting on social media during your case
6. Hire a personal injury lawyer with experience handling TBI claims

A strong case depends on both medical credibility and legal expertise.

 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much is a brain injury case worth after a car accident?

The value of a brain injury case varies greatly depending on the injury’s severity, how it impacts the victim’s life, and the strength of the medical and legal evidence. While mild cases might settle for under $100,000, severe TBIs can result in multimillion-dollar settlements. Factors such as lost earning potential, cost of long-term care, and pain and suffering all play a role in determining the final compensation amount.

Can I sue for memory loss after a car accident?

Yes. Memory loss is a common symptom of traumatic brain injuries and can have serious consequences on a person’s daily functioning and work ability. If a car accident caused you to develop short-term or long-term memory problems, you may be entitled to compensation for medical treatment, lost income, and emotional distress. You’ll need medical documentation linking the memory issues to the crash.

What if my brain injury wasn’t diagnosed right away?

It’s not uncommon for symptoms of a TBI to appear hours or even days after the accident. Delayed diagnosis doesn’t disqualify you from filing a claim, but it can complicate the process. That’s why it’s important to document all new or worsening symptoms and seek follow-up care. A qualified attorney can help prove the connection between the accident and your brain injury using medical records, expert opinions, and witness testimony.

Will insurance cover long-term brain damage?

Basic auto insurance policies may not fully cover long-term brain injury care. Insurance companies often try to limit payouts, especially in TBI cases that involve invisible symptoms. If the at-fault driver’s policy is insufficient, you may be able to recover additional funds through your own insurance or a personal injury lawsuit. A lawyer can help you explore all sources of compensation.

Do I need a lawyer for a brain injury claim?

Absolutely. Brain injury cases are medically complex and legally challenging. Insurance companies often dispute the severity or even the existence of a brain injury, especially if there are no visible symptoms. A personal injury attorney with experience in TBI cases can gather expert testimony, calculate damages, and negotiate with insurers—or take the case to court if necessary. Legal representation significantly increases your chances of receiving full compensation.

 

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., Today

If you or a loved one has suffered a brain injury in a car accident, don’t wait. These cases require immediate medical and legal action. The long-term costs can be overwhelming, and without proper representation, you may settle for far less than your claim is worth.

Contact our qualified brain injury attorney today to schedule a free case review. An experienced legal team will evaluate your claim, gather the necessary evidence, and fight to secure the compensation you deserve.