Liability in New Jersey Accidents Caused by Debris or Fallen Cargo

All Practice Areas

When you’re driving down a New Jersey highway and debris suddenly hits your vehicle—or you’re forced to swerve to avoid something falling off a truck—the experience can be terrifying and confusing. Who should be held responsible? What laws apply? And can you sue for damages?

This guide explores everything you need to know about New Jersey debris accident liability, including causes, legal responsibilities, how to prove fault, and what to do next.

 

Understanding Debris Accidents in New Jersey

What Are Debris-Related Crashes?

Debris-related crashes occur when an object—often from a moving vehicle—obstructs the roadway or collides with another vehicle. In most cases, this debris comes from unsecured cargo on commercial trucks or trailers.

How Common Are These Accidents?

According to national statistics, debris contributes to thousands of crashes each year, many of which result in injuries or fatalities. In New Jersey, where commercial trucking routes are heavily traveled, these accidents are a recurring problem.

 

Common Causes of Falling Cargo Accidents

1. Improperly Secured Loads

One of the most frequent causes is failing to use proper tie-downs, straps, or nets. When cargo shifts or becomes loose, it can fall into the path of other drivers.

2. Driver Negligence

Drivers are required to inspect their loads before and during transport. Skipping these checks or ignoring visible problems can lead to disaster.

3. Third-Party Loading Errors

In many commercial operations, outside contractors are responsible for loading trucks. If they load items improperly, the consequences can be severe.

4. Vehicle Defects or Maintenance Failures

Loose trailer doors, broken latches, or missing safety equipment can all contribute to cargo spills—even when the cargo itself was properly arranged.

 

Legal Foundations: Who Can Be Held Liable in NJ?

Understanding Negligence

In New Jersey, negligence occurs when someone fails to act with reasonable care, leading to an accident or injury. Proving negligence is key to holding someone liable in a debris-related crash.

Is the Truck Driver Always Responsible?

Not necessarily. A truck driver might be liable if they ignored inspection protocols or knowingly drove with an unsecured load. However, other parties may share responsibility.

When Is the Trucking Company at Fault?

Trucking companies can be held liable if:

• They failed to train drivers on load securement.
• They encouraged unsafe delivery practices.
• They neglected to maintain their vehicles.

What About Loaders and Contractors?

Third-party entities, such as warehouse workers or freight companies, may be liable if they improperly secured the load. Your attorney will examine who last handled the cargo before the accident.

 

What Laws Govern Cargo Securement in New Jersey?

New Jersey DOT Regulations

The New Jersey Department of Transportation enforces strict guidelines for securing loads. These laws require:

• Use of appropriate restraints (e.g., straps, chains).
• Regular inspections of cargo.
• Ensuring loads are balanced and covered when necessary.

Violating these regulations is often considered negligence.

Federal FMCSA Rules

Federal law also governs how cargo is secured on commercial trucks. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) mandates that cargo must:

• Be secured to prevent shifting or falling.
• Use tie-downs of sufficient strength.
• Be checked regularly throughout the trip.

Violation of FMCSA rules may result in fines, license suspension, and liability in civil lawsuits.

 

Can You Sue for Road Debris Accidents in NJ?

Yes—If Negligence Can Be Proven

If you were injured because of falling or unsecured cargo, you may be able to file a lawsuit. The success of your case depends on showing that the person or entity responsible failed to act with reasonable care.

What Damages Can Be Recovered?

Victims of these accidents may seek compensation for:

1. Emergency medical care and long-term treatment.
2. Lost wages or reduced earning capacity.
3. Pain, suffering, and emotional trauma.
4. Property damage to your car or personal items.

Even Indirect Accidents May Be Compensable

You don’t have to be directly hit by debris. If you crashed while swerving to avoid fallen cargo and suffered injuries, you may still have a valid claim under New Jersey’s comparative negligence laws.

 

How to Prove Fault in a Debris-Related Crash

Why Evidence Matters

In cases involving debris or falling cargo, proving fault can be more complicated than in a typical rear-end or T-bone collision. The success of your claim will often depend on what evidence you gather.

Types of Evidence That Can Help

Strong evidence includes:

1. Photos of the debris on the road.
2. Damage to your vehicle.
3. Police reports documenting the crash.
4. Dashcam or surveillance footage.
5. Witness statements from other drivers.

What If the Truck Keeps Driving?

In many cases, the vehicle that dropped the cargo is unaware and leaves the scene. If you didn’t catch the license plate, an attorney can investigate using traffic cameras or area surveillance to help identify the vehicle.

 

What to Do Immediately After the Accident

1. Ensure Safety First

Pull over as soon as it’s safe. Turn on hazard lights and check yourself and passengers for injuries.

2. Call 911 and File a Police Report

Even if the damage seems minor, you’ll need a police report to support your insurance claim or future legal case. Tell officers about any debris or fallen cargo that caused the crash.

3. Take Photos and Collect Information

Document everything, including the location, debris, your vehicle, and any other vehicles involved. If there are witnesses, ask for their contact information.

4. Seek Medical Attention Promptly

Some injuries, like whiplash or concussions, may not be obvious right away. A medical record created immediately after the crash can support your injury claim later.

 

Can You Still File a Claim If the Truck Isn’t Identified?

Yes—Through Uninsured Motorist Coverage

If you can’t identify the truck or company responsible, your own insurance policy may cover the damage under uninsured motorist (UM) provisions. Many policies include this type of coverage, especially in hit-and-run or unknown-party scenarios.

An Attorney Can Help Investigate

A skilled personal injury lawyer can work with investigators, review surveillance footage, or issue subpoenas to nearby businesses for security recordings.

 

Real-World Example: Debris-Related Crash on I-78

In one real case, a driver was traveling along I-78 when a mattress fell off a pickup truck in front of them. The driver swerved to avoid the mattress and collided with a guardrail, suffering neck and shoulder injuries.

The driver hired an attorney who used dashcam footage and traffic camera records to identify the truck. It turned out the mattress had been loosely tied down with only one strap, violating both NJ DOT and FMCSA regulations. The victim received a settlement that covered medical costs, vehicle repairs, and lost income.

 

Why Legal Representation Makes a Difference

These Cases Are Legally Complex

Filing a lawsuit for a debris-related accident involves proving negligence, identifying the liable party, dealing with insurance adjusters, and sometimes litigating in court. An experienced attorney knows how to navigate this process effectively.

You Deserve Full Compensation

Insurance companies often try to minimize payouts or claim that debris was an “act of God” or unavoidable. A lawyer can fight to ensure that your case is treated seriously and your losses are fully accounted for.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Debris Accidents in New Jersey

Can I file a claim if the debris didn’t hit my vehicle but caused me to crash?
Yes, you may still have a valid claim. In New Jersey, a driver can pursue compensation even if their vehicle was not directly struck by debris, as long as they can prove that the accident was caused by trying to avoid fallen cargo. For example, if you swerved to miss a ladder or box that fell off a truck and crashed into a barrier or another vehicle, that may still qualify as a negligence-based incident. The key is establishing that the presence of unsecured cargo on the roadway directly contributed to your accident.

Is the trucking company always responsible in a debris-related crash?
Not always, but they are often a central party in these cases. Liability depends on who had control over the cargo and who failed to secure it properly. The trucking company may be held responsible if they failed to train their drivers, did not enforce securement protocols, or ignored required inspections. However, if a third-party loading service handled the cargo, or if the driver was independently contracted and solely negligent, those parties might also be liable. An investigation is usually needed to determine fault.

What if the truck that dropped the debris drove away?
This is unfortunately common. Trucks may drop cargo without realizing it and continue on without stopping. If you cannot identify the truck or driver, you can still file a claim with your own insurance provider under uninsured motorist coverage. Additionally, a personal injury attorney may be able to help track down the vehicle using dashcam footage, eyewitness accounts, or traffic camera surveillance. Acting quickly improves the odds of locating the responsible party.

Can I still take legal action if I didn’t collect evidence at the scene?
While it’s always best to document the scene with photos and get a police report, the lack of immediate evidence doesn’t automatically eliminate your chances of recovering damages. A skilled lawyer may still be able to gather evidence after the fact, such as surveillance footage, highway maintenance reports, or statements from other witnesses. If you sought medical treatment and reported the incident in a timely manner, those records will also help support your claim.

Does insurance cover accidents caused by road debris?
In many cases, yes. If you have comprehensive or collision coverage, your policy may help pay for repairs to your vehicle. However, this does not cover injuries or allow you to recover pain and suffering damages unless you pursue a personal injury claim. If the debris was caused by an identifiable at-fault party, such as a trucking company or cargo loader, their liability insurance may cover both your property damage and personal injury claims.

 

Final Thoughts: Protecting Yourself After a Debris Accident

Falling cargo and unsecured load accidents are not just random accidents—they’re usually the result of negligence, poor training, or failure to follow the law. If you’ve been affected by one of these incidents, you have rights. With the right legal help, you can hold the responsible party accountable and recover compensation for your injuries and losses.

The key to success is acting quickly. Evidence disappears fast. Witnesses forget. And companies may try to dodge responsibility. Taking action now can make all the difference in the outcome of your claim.

 

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., Today

If you’ve been hurt or suffered damages due to falling cargo or road debris in New Jersey, don’t wait. Reach out to The Epstein Law Firm, P.A., today. We can evaluate your case, protect your rights, and help you pursue the compensation you deserve.

Legal guidance is just a phone call or email away. Don’t shoulder the burden alone—get the legal support you need today.