What to Expect During a New Jersey Motor Vehicle Accident Lawsuit

Most New Jersey car accident claims never become lawsuits. They are reported, investigated, negotiated, and settled with an insurance company. A lawsuit begins when that process is not enough — when fault is disputed, when an insurer will not pay what a claim is worth, or when the filing deadline is approaching and your rights need protecting. Knowing what happens next, stage by stage, makes the process much less intimidating.

This page walks through a New Jersey motor vehicle accident lawsuit from the work that happens before filing, through discovery, settlement efforts, and trial. It is general information, not a prediction about any one case. For the damages a claim can include, see our guide to recovering compensation for motor vehicle accident injuries in New Jersey.

The Epstein Law Firm

Injured in a New Jersey Car Accident?

Stone columns on the facade of a courthouse

The Epstein Law Firm can review your car accidents claim and explain the evidence, deadlines, and next steps that may apply.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Request a consultation

Before Suit: Treatment, the PIP Claim, Demand, and Negotiation

A lawsuit is built long before a complaint is filed. The first job is medical: get examined promptly, follow the treatment plan, and keep appointments. Gaps in care give insurers an argument that you were not badly hurt, and the medical records created during treatment become the core evidence of injury later.

At the same time, a personal injury protection (PIP) claim is opened with your own auto insurer. New Jersey is a no-fault state for these initial benefits, so PIP pays covered medical bills regardless of who caused the crash, up to the limits you selected. Under N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4, a standard policy provides medical benefits up to $250,000, although many drivers chose lower limits. Keep every bill, claim number, and explanation of benefits; a PIP dispute is separate from the lawsuit against the at-fault driver.

Once treatment has progressed enough to understand the injury, your lawyer usually sends a demand: a summary of fault, the medical evidence, lost wages, and the amount sought. Negotiation follows. Many claims settle here. When they do not — because the offer is too low, liability is denied, or a coverage problem needs a court to sort out — filing suit is the next step. Crashes involving several impacts and several insurers are especially likely to need that step, as our article on legal options after a multi-impact car accident explains.

Filing the Complaint in Superior Court, Law Division

A car accident lawsuit for more than $20,000 is filed in the Civil Part of the Law Division of New Jersey Superior Court, usually in the county where the crash happened or a party lives. The New Jersey Courts’ guide to lawsuits over $20,000 describes the basic filing packet: the complaint itself, a Civil Case Information Statement, and the filing fee.

The complaint is the document that starts the case. It names the plaintiff and defendants, states what happened, explains why the defendants are legally responsible, and asks for money damages. It does not have to prove the case on day one, but it frames everything that follows, so details such as the date, location, and parties must be right. A jury trial can be requested in the filing.

One deadline controls this stage. Under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2, a personal injury action generally must be commenced within two years after the cause of action accrues — in most car accident cases, two years from the crash. Miss that deadline and the claim is usually lost, however strong it is. That is why lawyers sometimes file suit while negotiation is still going on: filing preserves the claim, and talks can continue afterward.

Service, the Answer, and the Shape of the Case

Filing alone does not bring the defendant into the case. The complaint and a summons must be formally delivered — served — on each defendant. The New Jersey Courts note that service can be made by a county sheriff’s officer, a private process server, or another adult with no connection to the case. Proof of service is filed with the court.

The defendant then answers. The Courts’ civil guide states that a defendant who receives a summons has 35 days to respond, and that failing to respond can lead to a default judgment. In practice, the answer is usually filed by the defendant’s insurance company’s lawyers. It responds to each allegation, raises defenses, and may include a counterclaim or claims against other parties who might share fault.

After the answer, the court assigns the case a track based on its complexity, which helps set how long discovery will run. From here, the case moves on two rails at once: the formal exchange of evidence described next, and continuing settlement discussion, which never really stops.

Discovery: Interrogatories, Documents, and Depositions

Discovery is the longest stage of most lawsuits, and the one clients feel most directly. Its purpose is simple: each side must show the other its evidence before trial, so there are no surprises and both sides can value the case honestly. The Courts explain that once an answer is filed, the discovery period begins, and each side can review the other’s evidence.

Interrogatories are written questions answered in writing, under oath. Expect questions about the crash, your injuries and treatment, prior accidents or conditions, lost work, and insurance. Your lawyer will help you answer completely and accurately; those answers can be used at trial, so care matters more than speed.

Document exchange follows. Medical records and bills, the police report, photographs, wage records, and insurance information move between the sides, usually through formal requests for production. This is where keeping your own file — bills, letters, photos of the vehicles and the scene — pays off.

Depositions are sworn question-and-answer sessions, recorded by a court reporter, usually in a lawyer’s office rather than a courtroom. The defense lawyer will ask about the crash, your health before and after, your treatment, and how the injuries affect daily life. There is no judge present for most depositions. Preparation is straightforward: review the records your lawyer gives you, answer only what is asked, tell the truth, and say “I don’t remember” when that is the honest answer rather than guessing. Your lawyer sits beside you and can object to improper questions.

Expert reports typically come near the end of discovery. Treating doctors or retained experts may explain causation and permanency, and the defense will serve its own experts in response.

The Defense Medical Examination

At some point the defense will usually schedule a medical examination by a doctor it selects. Plaintiffs’ lawyers often call it a defense medical examination; it is also widely known as an independent medical examination, or IME. Whatever the label, understand what it is: an examination paid for by the defense, performed by a doctor who is not treating you and who will send a report to the defense.

The visit is usually brief. The doctor will ask how the crash happened, what hurts, and what treatment you have had, then do a physical examination focused on the injured areas. Be polite, be on time, and be consistent: describe your symptoms the same way you have described them to your own doctors and in your interrogatory answers. Do not exaggerate, and do not minimise either. Notes about what was asked, what was tested, and how long the examination lasted can help your lawyer later.

The examiner’s report may agree that you were injured, or it may say your problems predate the crash or have resolved. That disagreement is common, and it is one reason cases go to trial: each side presents its medical evidence and the jury decides what to believe. An IME report is evidence for the defense, not a ruling that ends your case.

Arbitration, Mediation, and Settlement Conferences

New Jersey pushes civil cases toward resolution without a trial, and the New Jersey Courts describe complementary dispute resolution (CDR) as the reason civil cases rarely reach a courtroom. Three settings matter most in car accident cases.

Court-annexed arbitration. Many automobile negligence cases are referred to arbitration under the court’s CDR program. As the Courts describe it, a neutral arbitrator — an experienced lawyer or a retired judge — hears arguments, reviews evidence, and renders a decision that is generally non-binding: a party who rejects the award can demand a trial de novo, meaning the case continues toward trial as if the arbitration had not decided it. Parties can also agree to voluntary binding arbitration, which is final. Separate insurance arbitrations also exist for disputes such as uninsured and underinsured motorist claims and PIP benefit disputes; those follow the insurance contract and its own procedures rather than the court case. Our page on uninsured and underinsured motorist accidents explains that coverage in more detail.

Mediation. In mediation, a neutral mediator helps the parties negotiate but does not decide anything, as the Courts’ civil mediation frequently asked questions explain. Sessions are confidential, and if the case settles, the agreement is written up and the case is dismissed; if it does not, the case simply continues toward trial.

Settlement conferences. Courts also hold settlement conferences, where a judge or neutral explores whether the gap between demand and offer can be closed. None of these settings requires you to accept a number. Their value is information: you learn how a neutral values the case before anyone risks a verdict.

Trial: Fault Percentages, Damages, and the Verbal Threshold

If the case does not settle, it is tried, usually to a jury in the Law Division. Each side presents testimony and exhibits, witnesses are cross-examined, and the jury is asked to decide two big questions: who was at fault and in what percentages, and what damages to award.

Fault percentages matter because of New Jersey’s comparative negligence law, N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1. Your damages are reduced by your own percentage of fault, and you recover nothing if your fault is greater than the defendants’ combined fault. A jury that finds $100,000 in damages and 20 percent fault on you produces an $80,000 award; a finding that you were mostly at fault ends the case.

The second gate is the verbal threshold, properly called the limitation on lawsuit option, in N.J.S.A. 39:6A-8. If that option applies to you, you cannot recover for pain and suffering — non-economic loss — unless your injury falls within a category the statute lists, such as death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement or scarring, a displaced fracture, loss of a fetus, or a permanent injury shown within a reasonable degree of medical probability. The statute also requires a physician certification early in the case supporting that the injury qualifies. Economic losses, such as medical bills and lost wages, are a separate question from this threshold. Drivers who chose the no-limitation option are not held to this gate.

Where a crash happened can shape the evidence at trial. Our review of the 25 most dangerous and deadly roads in New Jersey shows how road design, speed, and traffic patterns feature in these cases.

Verdict, Post-Trial Motions, Appeal, and Getting Paid

A verdict is not always the last word. Either side can file post-trial motions asking the trial court, for example, for a new trial or to change the judgment, and the Courts’ civil FAQ notes that a party can file a motion for reconsideration or take an appeal to the Appellate Division. Appeals argue that legal errors affected the outcome; they are not a second trial with new evidence, and they add time.

If a judgment stands, it must still be collected. In most car accident cases an insurer pays the judgment or settlement, but when collection steps are needed, the Courts’ guide to collecting money in a civil case describes tools such as writs of execution, bank levies, and wage execution — and cautions that the court cannot guarantee payment. Settlements are usually documented with a release, and the case is then dismissed.

On timing, be realistic. The pre-suit stage can take months while you treat, discovery commonly runs for many more months after filing, and a case that goes through arbitration, mediation, and trial can take a year or more after filing — sometimes considerably longer. Cases also settle at every stage, including after suit is filed and even during trial, so a long timeline does not mean your case will necessarily use all of it.

Related Car Accident Resources and Reading

These pages cover the questions that most often come up alongside a lawsuit:

The Epstein Law Firm represents injured people from its office at 340 West Passaic Street, Rochelle Park, NJ 07662. If you have been told a claim is denied, undervalued, or close to a deadline, a review of the file can clarify where your case stands in this process.

The Epstein Law Firm

Questions About a New Jersey Car Accident Claim?

Stone columns on the facade of a courthouse

The Epstein Law Firm can review the evidence, insurance issues, and next steps that may matter in your car accidents claim.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Request a consultation

Notable Results

Selected case results obtained by The Epstein Law Firm:

$13.585 Million · $10 Million · $4.25 Million

$13.585 Million — Confidential Settlement

Flagship Result

The Epstein Law Firm obtained a $13.585 million confidential settlement — the largest result listed on the firm’s verdicts and settlements page.

$10 Million — Confidential Settlement

Negligent Care

The Epstein Law Firm obtained a confidential $10 million settlement in a case exposing critical lapses in training and oversight within the home health care industry, holding the negligent organization accountable.

$4.25 Million — Confidential Settlement

Wrongful Death — Motor Vehicle

The Epstein Law Firm obtained a $4.25 million confidential settlement in a wrongful death and survival action for a Teaneck husband and father who died after a tire fell off his car, causing it to flip and catch fire. A major mechanic operations company was at fault for failing to attach the tire properly.

View all verdicts and settlements →

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case is different and must be evaluated on its own facts.

Professional Recognition

2026 Top Lawyer Badge awarded to Michael J. Epstein of The Epstein Law Firm.Michael J. Epstein — Best Lawyers recognition

Recognition applies to the named attorneys and selection years. See the linked profiles for details.

No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey.

Awards & Professional Profiles

No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey. Rating methodology

Related The Epstein Law Firm Videos and Social Posts

Frequently Asked Questions About New Jersey Car Accident Lawsuits

Below are answers to common questions about New Jersey car accident lawsuits. This information is general and not legal advice — contact our office for guidance about your specific situation.

How long does a New Jersey car accident lawsuit take?

There is no fixed schedule, and anyone who guarantees one is guessing. The work before filing can take months while you treat, discovery after filing commonly runs for many more months, and a case that goes through arbitration or mediation to trial can take a year or more after filing, sometimes considerably longer.

Two clocks run at once. The filing deadline under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2 is generally two years, while the pace after filing depends on the court’s track, how much discovery is needed, and whether the case settles. Many cases resolve well before trial, at any stage.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2, two-year personal injury limit; New Jersey Courts, lawsuits over $20,000

What happens after a car accident lawsuit is filed in New Jersey?

The complaint and summons are served on each defendant, who must then answer. The New Jersey Courts state that a defendant has 35 days to respond to a summons, and that failing to respond can lead to a default judgment. In most car cases the defendant’s insurer provides the defence lawyer who files the answer.

After the answer, the court manages the case, discovery begins, and the sides exchange evidence. Settlement discussions usually continue throughout, and the court may refer the case to arbitration or mediation before any trial date.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, lawsuits over $20,000; New Jersey Courts, Civil and Law Division frequently asked questions

What is discovery in a car accident lawsuit?

Discovery is the formal exchange of evidence after the case is filed. It includes written questions called interrogatories, requests for documents such as medical records, bills, photographs, and wage records, expert reports, and depositions. The New Jersey Courts explain that once an answer is filed, the discovery period begins and each side can review the other’s evidence.

Discovery is usually the longest stage of a lawsuit. It is also what allows both sides to value the case realistically, which is why many cases settle during or shortly after discovery rather than at trial.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, lawsuits over $20,000; New Jersey Courts, Civil and Law Division frequently asked questions

Will I have to testify at a deposition?

In most car accident lawsuits, yes. A deposition is sworn testimony taken before trial, recorded by a court reporter, with the defence lawyer asking questions about the crash, your medical history and treatment, and how the injuries affect your work and daily life. Your own lawyer attends with you and prepares you beforehand.

There is usually no judge present, but the testimony is under oath and can be used at trial, so accuracy matters. Answer only what is asked, do not guess, and say so honestly when you do not remember something.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, Civil and Law Division frequently asked questions; New Jersey Courts, Civil Practice Division

What is an independent medical examination, and what should I expect?

It is an examination by a doctor selected and paid by the defence, not by your treating doctors. The examiner reviews records, asks how the crash happened and what symptoms you have, performs a focused physical examination, and writes a report for the defence about causation, treatment, and whether the injury is permanent.

Expect a relatively short visit, and be consistent: describe your symptoms as you have to your own doctors. The report is the defence’s evidence, not a decision in the case. If the examiner disagrees with your doctors, a jury may ultimately have to decide which medical view to accept.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, Civil Practice Division; Epstein Law Firm, car accidents

What is arbitration, and can it decide my case?

In court-annexed arbitration, a neutral arbitrator — an experienced lawyer or retired judge — hears the case in a less formal setting and issues an award. As the New Jersey Courts describe the program, that award is generally non-binding: a party who rejects it can demand a trial de novo and continue toward trial.

Arbitration can decide a case for good when the parties accept the award, or when they have agreed in advance to voluntary binding arbitration. Separate insurance arbitrations can also resolve uninsured or underinsured motorist and PIP disputes under the policy’s own procedures.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, arbitration; New Jersey Courts, Civil CDR program information

Do most car accident cases settle before trial?

Yes. The New Jersey Courts state that almost 98 percent of civil cases are resolved without a trial, largely through complementary dispute resolution, and their civil guide notes that only about 2 percent of civil cases ever go to trial. Car accident lawsuits follow the same pattern: most settle during negotiation, discovery, arbitration, or mediation.

Settling is a choice, not an obligation. A settlement trades the certainty of an agreed amount for giving up the chance of a larger verdict, and it also avoids the risk of a defence verdict. Your lawyer should explain both sides of that trade before you decide.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, Civil CDR program information; New Jersey Courts, lawsuits over $20,000

What is the verbal threshold, and how does it affect my case?

The verbal threshold is the limitation on lawsuit option in N.J.S.A. 39:6A-8. If it applies to you, you generally cannot recover pain-and-suffering damages unless your injury falls in a listed category, such as a displaced fracture, significant disfigurement or scarring, loss of a fetus, or a permanent injury shown within a reasonable degree of medical probability.

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance explains the same choice to consumers buying a standard policy, and notes that it does not affect claims for economic damages such as medical expenses and lost wages. Which option you selected should be checked at the start of any case.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 39:6A-8, limitation on lawsuit option; New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, Standard Auto Insurance Policy

What happens if I am partly at fault for the accident?

New Jersey follows modified comparative negligence under N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1. Your damages are reduced by your own percentage of fault, so a $100,000 award with 20 percent fault on you becomes $80,000. If your fault is greater than the combined fault of the defendants, you recover nothing.

That is why early statements to insurers matter: an adjuster who can push your share of fault up reduces what the company pays, and past the halfway point it ends the claim. Fault percentages are ultimately decided by agreement in a settlement or by the jury at trial.

Sources: N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, comparative negligence; New Jersey Courts, Civil Practice Division

What does it cost to pursue a car accident lawsuit?

Court costs exist even in a strong case. The New Jersey Courts list a filing fee of $250 for a Law Division complaint, and cases also involve costs for service, records, experts, and transcripts as they move forward. Those amounts are separate from any attorney fee, and you should ask how they are handled in your case.

The Epstein Law Firm offers a free case evaluation, and personal injury cases are handled on a contingency fee — no fee unless we win — rather than an hourly rate. Before signing, ask what percentage applies, how case costs are treated, and get the agreement in writing.

Sources: New Jersey Courts, lawsuits over $20,000; Epstein Law Firm, car accidents

The Epstein Law Firm

Discuss Your New Jersey Car Accident

Stone columns on the facade of a courthouse

Tell The Epstein Law Firm what happened and get clear guidance about your injury claim and legal options.

Call now

(201) 231-7847
Request a consultation

What Our Clients Say

These excerpts describe experiences with the firm. They are not identified as cases in this practice area and do not predict another outcome.

“April was very professional and helped us tremendously. She explained everything thoroughly so that we understood the process from start to finish. We appreciate everything she did for us. We could not have had a better attorney.”

— Agnes · Read the full Google review

“Throughout the experience, I felt supported, well informed, and confident in the guidance I received. I truly appreciate your diligence, professionalism, and commitment to achieving a fair and favorable outcome. I would confidently recommend your firm to anyone seeking high-quality legal representation.”

— Elisa · Read the full Google review

All Practice Areas

All Practice Areas

Schedule Your Free Case Evaluation

201-231-7847 Free case evaluation