Can an Injured Worker See Their Own Doctor?

All Practice Areas

Navigating the workers’ compensation process after a workplace injury can be overwhelming. One of the most common questions injured employees face is whether they can choose their own doctor for treatment or if they must see an employer-mandated physician. Understanding your rights is essential to ensuring you receive proper care while safeguarding your claim. This article explores employer-mandated care, state-specific rules, and your options if you are dissatisfied with your doctor.

 

What Is Employer-Mandated Medical Care?

Employer-mandated medical care refers to situations where workers’ compensation rules require injured employees to visit a specific doctor or clinic approved by their employer or insurer. This system is designed to streamline treatment, but it can leave employees feeling like their healthcare choices are limited.

Why Do Employers Assign Doctors?
Employers or insurers often assign doctors to:

• Ensure treatment aligns with workers’ compensation guidelines.
• Monitor and manage medical expenses related to claims.
• Maintain continuity of care with providers familiar with workplace injuries.

While this system has benefits for employers, it can create challenges for injured workers who may not feel comfortable with the assigned doctor or question the quality of care they’re receiving.

 

State-Specific Rules for Choosing a Doctor

The ability to choose your own doctor after a workplace injury largely depends on the state in which you live. Workers’ compensation laws vary significantly across the United States, making it critical to understand the specific rules in your jurisdiction.

States That Allow Workers to Choose Their Doctor
In some states, injured workers have the right to select their treating physician from the beginning. This can include:

• Personal family doctors.
• Specialists who are familiar with the worker’s medical history.

States That Require Employer-Approved Doctors
Other states mandate that injured workers visit a doctor chosen from a list approved by the employer or insurer. These states aim to ensure compliance with workers’ compensation treatment protocols.

Checking State Laws
To determine your rights:

• Review workers’ compensation laws for your state.
• Consult with a workers’ compensation lawyer to clarify any legal gray areas.

For example:

• California: Injured workers can choose their own doctor if they pre-designate one before the injury occurs.
• Florida: Employees must visit an employer-approved physician unless they receive authorization for a change.

 

Switching Doctors During Workers’ Comp Treatment

If you are unhappy with the care provided by the employer-designated doctor, you may have options to change physicians. However, this process varies by state and often requires authorization.

Steps to Change Your Doctor

• Request a Change from Your Employer or Insurer
  Many states require you to formally request a change in treating physician. This may involve filling out specific forms or submitting a written request.
• Seek a Second Opinion
  In states that allow it, injured workers may consult another physician for a second opinion. Be aware that this visit might need prior approval from your insurer.
• File a Formal Appeal
  If your request to switch doctors is denied, you may need to file an appeal with your state’s workers’ compensation board.
  
  

When Can You Switch Doctors?
Switching doctors is typically permitted if:

• You believe the assigned doctor is not providing adequate care.
• There is a conflict of interest (e.g., the doctor prioritizes the employer’s interests).
• Your condition is not improving under the current treatment plan.

 

Independent Medical Examination (IME): What to Expect

An Independent Medical Examination (IME) is a key part of many workers’ compensation claims. This examination is conducted by a neutral doctor to provide an unbiased evaluation of your condition and treatment needs.

Purpose of an IME

• Verify the extent of your injury.
• Determine if your condition aligns with the reported workplace incident.
• Assess whether the prescribed treatment plan is appropriate.

Preparing for an IME

• Bring all relevant medical records and documentation of your injury.
• Be honest and accurate about your symptoms.
• Avoid exaggerating or downplaying your condition.

An IME can influence the outcome of your claim, so take it seriously and consult a lawyer if you have concerns about the process.

 

Common Challenges and Solutions

Navigating workers’ compensation can be frustrating, especially if you feel your medical care is inadequate. Here are common challenges injured workers face and actionable solutions:

Dissatisfaction with Employer-Assigned Doctor
Solution: Request a change in treating physician or seek a second opinion if allowed by your state.

Confusion About State-Specific Rules
Solution: Research your state’s workers’ compensation laws or consult a lawyer specializing in workplace injuries.

Delays in Authorization for Treatment
Solution: Document all communications with your employer and insurer. Escalate unresolved issues to your state’s workers’ compensation board.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I Have to See My Employer’s Doctor for a Work Injury?
It depends on your state. In some states, you must see an employer-approved doctor, while others allow you to choose your own.

Can I Choose My Own Doctor for Workers’ Comp Cases?
In states that allow it, you can choose your own doctor. In others, you may need to seek authorization or select from an approved list.

How Can I Switch Doctors During Treatment?
Submit a request to your employer or insurer, and be prepared to provide valid reasons for the change. Consult a lawyer if your request is denied.

Is a Second Opinion Allowed in Workers’ Comp Cases?
Many states allow injured workers to seek a second opinion, though prior approval may be required.

What Happens During an IME?
An IME involves a neutral doctor evaluating your condition to verify your claim and treatment needs.

 

Key Takeaways for Injured Workers

Understand Your Rights
State laws determine whether you can choose your doctor or must see an employer-assigned physician.

Explore Your Options
If dissatisfied with your care, you may be able to request a change in treating physician or seek a second opinion.

Consult Legal Help
Workers’ compensation laws are complex. A lawyer can provide clarity and help you advocate for the care you need.

 

Contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A. Today

If you’re feeling unsure about your rights or struggling to navigate workers’ compensation rules, consulting an experienced lawyer is essential. A legal professional can guide you through the process, help you understand state-specific laws, and ensure you receive the care you deserve. Don’t leave your recovery to chance—contact The Epstein Law Firm, P.A. today for personalized assistance.